OUSTON,
Aug. 8 — Weathered red brick exterior? Check. Concrete floors? Check.
Nineteen-foot-high ceilings? Check. Throw in some gargoyles and voilà, a
"faux loft."
Developers here are tearing down perfectly good buildings or acquiring
empty lots to make room for what look like century-old factories. Inside
are loft-style apartments that try to mimic the faded mystique of
Manhattan neighborhoods like SoHo or TriBeCa.
The trend is taking root in several cities without much of a loft
tradition, including Las Vegas, Atlanta and Washington. But its most
active and creative proponents are here in Houston, the nation's
fourth-largest city, where migration from the suburbs to areas closer to
downtown has become increasingly fashionable in recent years.
All the activity has produced red-brick developments like the
Manhattan, a new building in the high-end Galleria shopping district.
Described by its creators as "reminiscent of the historic buildings
that flanked New York City's Fifth and Park Avenues in the late 19th and
early 20th centuries," it has 63 loft-style residences and 22
different floor plans.
The lofts in the Manhattan building have their own evocative names,
like the Met, Brooklyn and Times Square. (One of the largest and most
expensive is Astoria.) They come with features like terraces and whirlpool
tubs and have buildingwide amenities like a concierge, resort-style pool
and wine cellar.
The Manhattan and other buildings like it, with names like Gotham,
Metropolis and Renoir, have caught on mainly with young professionals and
retiring baby boomers seeking more of an urban lifestyle and quicker
commutes. The trend has also touched off a lively discussion among urban
planners and architecture critics here.
"I think the faux lofts are atrocious," said Stephen Fox, a
professor of architectural history at Rice University. "They're an
expedient, unimaginative and opportunistic way to capitalize on the desire
for the urban experience. They're also in keeping with the Houstonian
ethos of borrowing styles from everywhere."
Houston, of course, has long been home to an amalgam of styles, like
the intricate play between the unassuming Menil Collection museum,
designed by Renzo Piano, and the simple gray bungalow houses surrounding
it; or the ornate Mediterranean campus of Rice University, an oasis tucked
away within the city's seemingly endless collection of low-slung,
nondescript neighborhoods. Just a handful of historic buildings from the
19th and early 20th centuries remain.
Some residents of the old neighborhoods in which faux loft developments
are being built, like the traditionally black Third Ward area south of
downtown, view the new apartments with skepticism and even disdain.
Madgelean Bush, a longtime resident of the Third Ward and executive
director of the Martin Luther King Jr. Community Center, said the faux
lofts were an example of how Houston does not believe in rehabilitating
what it already has.
"I view it as a takeover where the poor are pushed out to make
room for rich folks who want to live a kind of fantasy life," Ms.
Bush said.
Genuine loft projects have been developed here since the early 1990's,
with investors renovating old hotels and warehouses in and around
Houston's futuristic downtown. One prominent real estate developer, the
Randall Davis Company, branched out into faux lofts after converting an
Art Deco building that once housed the Armor Automobile Company into a
loft-style community called Hogg Palace.
The developer's first faux loft building was Metropolis, with large
balconies, sweeping views of downtown and five rooftop gargoyle guardians
staring down at passers-by. Next came an inspirational shift with Renoir,
an edifice with 82 one- and two-bedroom loft apartments intended to evoke
Baron Haussmann's 19th-century Paris on the exterior. The Renoir has a
resort-style pool, reached through a stepped travertine terrace.
Most of the faux lofts are not cheap, whether sold as condominiums, or
rented. Apartments in the Renoir, for example, were priced from $200,000
to more than $800,000, and have nearly sold out. Randall Davis, owner of
the development firm of the same name, said "an attention to detail
when building from scratch allows you to take it to a higher level."
"Anyone can expose an air-conditioning duct and call it a
loft," Mr. Davis said. "People like something luxurious on the
inside that looks on the outside like it's been there a while."
There are many reasons faux lofts are catching on here. Houston, the
center of a metropolitan region of more than four million people, remains
the only major city in the United States without significant zoning
regulations, making it easier for developers to build in any style
wherever they please. Houston has few taboos about tearing down old
buildings to make way for new structures — even faux lofts built to look
old.
"There's an impulse to reconstruct the past to suit the city's
needs," said Stephen Klineberg, a professor of sociology at Rice
University.
An aversion to zoning also enabled Houston in recent years to grow in
several directions at once, begetting the sprawl that now defines the
city. Motorists here drive more miles per capita each day than residents
in any other American city, according to a study released last month by
the Surface Transportation Policy Project in Washington. The study said
each Houstonian drives an average of 37.6 miles a day, a 53 percent
increase from the early 1990's.
With more people in Houston seeking to live closer to where they work,
apartment construction has recently skyrocketed. Houston led the nation in
apartment building in January, with the number of units under construction
climbing 73 percent, to 10,436, from 6,043 in the month last year,
according to MP/F Research, a real estate analysis company.
"I don't think the faux lofts would go over well in a place with a
lot of historical buildings," said Paul Sternberg, a lawyer and
native of New Orleans who moved to a loft in the Renoir building after
leasing his home to an energy company executive. "But here it just
seems natural to want something that feels a little old. The high ceilings
are also a plus."
Most faux lofts come with details like separate bedrooms, granite
countertops, high arched windows, hardwood floors and Romeo and Juliet
balconies. Some are as large as 4,200 square feet and even include
Corinthian-style columns and on-site health clubs. Few ever appear as
barren as genuine lofts.
The appeal of faux lofts has begun to extend beyond urban areas near
downtown, with one faux loft project in the Woodlands, a large suburban
enclave on Houston's northern fringe, under development by Threshold
Interests, a company that had already converted two downtown buildings
into lofts.
Coming amid a broad building boom, this burst of loft-building has
added to concern that Houston may be on the cusp of an apartment glut if
the economy remains soft. Even some of the faux lofts have started
offering special deals to lure tenants, like a month's free rent on a
12-month lease. Some faux lofts already throw in extras like a cafe on
premises with free fast Internet connections and espresso or cooking
lessons with a gourmet chef.
The faux lofts have generally been able to keep charging relatively
high rents for Houston, although they still may not approach the prices of
lofts in Manhattan. Sabine Street Lofts, a new building on the edge of
downtown that looks like an old factory, charges about $1,700 for a
one-bedroom unit and roughly $2,450 for a two-bedroom loft. The average
rent for an apartment in Houston is $611 a month, according to Apartment
Data Services, a company that tracks rental rates.
It is hard to quantify exactly how many faux loft buildings have been
built across the country, because they form a relatively new category. But
traditional loft projects are growing in popularity. Sharon Park, who runs
a National Park Service program providing tax credits to companies for
rehabilitating historic buildings, said the number of projects approved by
her office had grown 5 to 10 percent a year since the late 1990's. Nearly
half of the projects involved some form of housing, including lofts, she
said.
Though the arbiters of taste may frown on the faux lofts, urban
theorists are mostly welcoming them as a healthy example of repopulating
an urban center that had been left to decay. One such believer is David
Crossley, president of the Gulf Coast Institute, a Houston group
encouraging greater use of public transportation and improved air quality.
"I don't care about the style of the things,"
Mr. Crossley said. "If it helps us feel like we're living in a city
again, then I'm all for it."